Grand National Weights 2009: Competition
*******DENMAN UPDATE***********
In light of the withdrawl of Denman we will allow an additional entry from those who have already made their selections. The latest entry will override the previous and will be the final, counting entry. If you choose not to update your entry then the exisiting figures will be used. NO FURTHER CHANGES WILL BE PERMITTED.
The weights for the 2009 Grand National will be published on Tuesday February 10th and as a number of you have been trying to work out what burden your fancies will have to carry, we thought we would run a competition to coincide with the issuing of the weights.
All you have to do is nominate what weight the following horses will be allocated on February 10th and then complete a tiebreaker of EXACTLY how many horses you think will be left in the entries after the publication of the first weights on Tuesday i.e how many horses will be allocated a weight.
The horses we would like you to try and work out weights for are:
Hear The Echo
Butlers Cabin
Comply Or Die
Himalayan Trail
War Of Attrition
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February =
Just cut and paste the above paragraph together with your ideas of each horses weight and the number of entries on Tuesday.
You get 10 points for every horse’s weight you get exactly right and 5 points if you are 1lb out either way (higher or lower). Any other weight scores 0.
In the unlikely event of a tie and matching tiebreakers we will provide an additional tiebreaker.
Entries for this competiton will be accepted up to 10am on Tuesday 10th February.
In the event of one or more of the featured horses not actually featuring in the weights then just the remaining horses will count
Only one entry per person please and there can be no editing of entries so don’t enter until you are sure you have your final version.
The exciting prize for this competition is twofold. The first part of the prize is a copy of Weatherby’s Aintree and Punchestown Festival Betting Guide 2009. An invaluable guide for all those amongst us who are interested in trends and this year it has been extended to cover the Punchestown Festival as well as the main focus of our attention, Aintree.
In addition to this we will also give the winner the chance to write his or her own preview of the Grand National for publication on Grand National Guide. You will have a maximum of 350 words to give all our Grand National readers your ideas behind what will win the great race and why.
We reserve the right to edit the winning entry where necessary.
Good luck to all and let’s try and get as many entries as possible – tell your mates!!!!






This post has 48 comments
#1
February 5th, 2009 18:26
So to give you an idea of how we want entries to look:
Hear The Echo 10-0
Butlers Cabin 10-0
Comply Or Die 10-0
Himalayan Trail 10-0
War Of Attrition 10-0
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 200
The above figures are just a demonstration – hopefully you will be much more accurate!
#2
February 5th, 2009 19:43
Hear The Echo 10-7
Butlers Cabin 11-1
Comply Or Die 11-9
Himalayan Trail 10-2
War Of Attrition 10-5
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 80
#3
February 6th, 2009 10:47
Someone has to be first, so here we go…
Hear The Echo 9-12
Butlers Cabin 9-2
Comply Or Die 10-10
Himalayan Trail 9-4
War Of Attrition 11-2
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 122
#4
February 6th, 2009 11:29
Hear The Echo 9-09
Butlers Cabin 8-13
Comply Or Die 10-09
Himalayan Trail 9-01
War Of Attrition 10-13
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 121
#5
February 6th, 2009 13:01
I will go with;
Hear The Echo 9-13
Butlers Cabin 9-03
Comply Or Die 10-11
Himalayan Trail 9-06
War Of Attrition 11-04
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 120
#6
February 6th, 2009 15:20
My stab:
WAR OF ATTRITION 10-13
COMPLY OR DIE 10-10
HEAR THE ECHO 9-11
HIMALAYAN TRAIL 9-04
BUTLER’S CABIN 9-01
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 118
If by some hugely unlikely event I win you can give the guide to whoever is second as I already ordered my copy from wetherby’s
#7
February 6th, 2009 16:52
WAR OF ATTRITION 10-12
COMPLY OR DIE 10-8
HIMALAYAN TRAIL 9-4
BUTLERS CABIN 9-1
117 ENTRIES
#8
February 6th, 2009 16:54
MISSED HEAR THE ECHO
WAR OF ATTRITION 10-12
COMPLY OR DIE 10-8
HEAR THE ECHO 9-12
HIMALAYAN TRAIL 9-4
BUTLERS CABIN 9-1
117 ENTRIES
#9
February 6th, 2009 19:56
War Of Attrition 11-2
Comply Or Die 10-6
Hear The Echo 9-6
Himalayan Trail 8-13
Butlers Cabin 8-10
122 entries
#10
February 6th, 2009 21:22
Hear The Echo 9-7
Butlers Cabin 8-11
Comply Or Die 10-4
Himalayan Trail 8-12
War Of Attrition 10-13
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 119
#11
February 6th, 2009 21:41
Ok..
Hear The Echo 9-11
Butlers Cabin 9-01
Comply Or Die 10-4
Himalayan Trail 9-03
War Of Attrition 11-03
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 121
#12
February 6th, 2009 23:07
Hear The Echo 9-13
Butlers Cabin 9-3
Comply Or Die 10-4
Himalayan Trail 9-5
War Of Attrition 10-11
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 121
#13
February 7th, 2009 16:49
Hear The Echo 9-12
Butlers Cabin 9-3
Comply Or Die 10-9
Himalayan Trail 9-7
War Of Attrition 11-1
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February =117
#14
February 7th, 2009 22:10
Hear The Echo 9-9
Butlers Cabin 9-0
Comply Or Die 10-4
Himalayan Trail 9-1
War Of Attrition 10-13
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 116
#15
February 8th, 2009 00:14
Hear The Echo 10-0
Butlers Cabin 9-4
Comply Or Die 10-11
Himalayan Trail 9-6
War Of Attrition 11-3
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 122
#16
February 8th, 2009 14:57
Hear The Echo 10-1
Butlers Cabin 9-5
Comply Or Die 10-11
Himalayan Trail 9-7
War Of Attrition 11-3
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 121
#17
February 8th, 2009 21:00
Hear The Echo 9-04
Butlers Cabin 9-09
Comply Or Die 10-12
Himalayan Trail 9-10
War Of Attrition 11-6
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 116
#18
February 8th, 2009 21:15
Hear The Echo 9-13
Butlers Cabin 9-9
Comply Or Die 10-7
Himalayan Trail 9-11
War Of Attrition 11-3
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 114
#19
February 9th, 2009 07:59
Hear The Echo 10-06
Butlers Cabin 10-09
Comply Or Die 11-03
Himalayan Trail 9-09
War Of Attrition 11-08
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 118
I’m just an amateur and in it for fun so would pass over over the oportunity to write a GN review!
#20
February 9th, 2009 10:57
Admin – any chance we can revise our lists based on the news Denman is now not running?
#21
February 9th, 2009 12:47
Hi everyone,
Thanks for your interest so far and in light of Denman not going to be involved we though it only fair to allow you all to have another go if you so wish. Please read the update at the top of the page. ONLY YOUR LATEST ENTRY WILL COUNT.
#22
February 9th, 2009 13:42
Hear The Echo 11-2
Butlers Cabin 10-10
Comply Or Die 11-6
Himalayan Trail 10-11
War Of Attrition 11-9
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 120
#23
February 9th, 2009 14:35
Always keen to get stuck in, so here is my revised assessment in the absence of Denman;
Hear The Echo 10-1
Butlers Cabin 9-5
Comply Or Die 10-13
Himalayan Trail 9-7
War Of Attrition 11-5
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 120
#24
February 9th, 2009 15:05
Here is my revised list after the Denman news…
Hear The Echo 10-0
Butlers Cabin 9-2
Comply Or Die 10-10
Himalayan Trail 9-3
War Of Attrition 11-3
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 119
#25
February 9th, 2009 15:07
Revised list
Hear The Echo 10-4
Butlers Cabin 9-9
Comply Or Die 10-13
Himalayan Trail 9-10
War Of Attrition 11-8
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 116
#26
February 9th, 2009 15:11
Hear The Echo 9-13
Butlers Cabin 9-03
Comply Or Die 10-13
Himalayan Trail 9-05
War Of Attrition 11-03
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 120
#27
February 9th, 2009 15:50
Revised list
Hear The Echo 10-4
Butlers Cabin 9-08
Comply Or Die 10-11
Himalayan Trail 9-10
War Of Attrition 11-10
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 119
#28
February 9th, 2009 15:59
Hear The Echo 10-3
Butlers Cabin 9-13
Comply Or Die 11-3
Himalayan Trail 10-1
War Of Attrition 11-10
Tie Breaker – 116
#29
February 9th, 2009 16:42
February 6th, 2009 at 1:01 pm
I will go with;
Hear The Echo 10-00
Butlers Cabin 9-03
Comply Or Die 11-01
Himalayan Trail 9-06
War Of Attrition 11-09
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 120
#30
February 9th, 2009 17:23
war of attrition 11-7
comply or die 10-11
hear the echo 9-13
himalayan trail 9-6
butlers cabin 9-3
119 entries
#31
February 9th, 2009 17:24
hooray! this is such fun
hooray! we get another go
but oh! If I win I have to write a review yikes!
Hear The Echo 10-04
Butlers Cabin 9-09
Comply Or Die 11-02
Himalayan Trail 9-12
War Of Attrition 11-08
COD doesn’t come off so lightly now ey:(
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February =117 stick!
#32
February 9th, 2009 17:48
After Denman’s departure
Hear The Echo 10-7
Butlers Cabin 9-11
Comply Or Die 10-7
Himalayan Trail 10-01
War Of Attrition 11-10
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 119
#33
February 9th, 2009 18:11
hear the echo 10-6
butlers cabin 9-9
comply or die 11-00
himalayan trail 9-11
war of attrition 11-8
tiebreaker.number of horses entered at tuesday
10th february=118
#34
February 9th, 2009 18:22
Hear The Echo 10-2
Butlers Cabin 9-11
Comply Or Die 10-9
Himalayan Trail 9-09
War Of Attrition 11-10
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 113
#35
February 9th, 2009 18:44
My revised list after the Denman withdrawal;
Hear The Echo 10-1
Butlers Cabin 9-5
Comply Or Die 10-13
Himalayan Trail 9-9
War Of Attrition 11-5
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 118
#36
February 9th, 2009 20:29
War of Attrition 11 10
Butlers Cabin 10 10
Comply or Die 11 1
Himalayan Trail 9 12
War of Attrition 11 10
Tiebreaker 116
#37
February 9th, 2009 20:31
Sorry left out Hear the echo and put
in WoA twice.
Hear the Echo 10 3
#38
February 9th, 2009 20:48
Don’t forget entries must be in by 10am tomorrow morning – anyone attmepting to enter after that time will not be included. So get your entries in as soon as possible!
We want to see who really knows their stuff!
#39
February 9th, 2009 22:40
hear the echo 10-04
Butlers cabin 9-09
Comply or die 11-05
Himalayan trail 9-12
War of attrition 11-10
111 ENTRYS
#40
February 9th, 2009 22:55
Hear The Echo 10-08
Butlers Cabin 10-04
Comply Or Die 11-4
Himalayan Trail 10-05
War Of Attrition 11-10
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 114
#41
February 10th, 2009 00:26
My stab:
WAR OF ATTRITION 11-10
COMPLY OR DIE 11-7
HEAR THE ECHO 10-8
HIMALAYAN TRAIL 10-01
BUTLER’S CABIN 9-13
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 116
If by some hugely unlikely event I win you can give the guide to whoever is second as I already ordered my copy from wetherby’s
#42
February 10th, 2009 01:25
Hear The Echo 10-4
Butlers Cabin 9-10
Comply Or Die 10-8
Himalayan Trail 9-10
War Of Attrition 11-0
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February = 107
The above figures are just a demonstration – hopefully you will be much more accurate!
#43
February 10th, 2009 06:13
Revised list on account of Denman and my own deliberations:-
Hear The Echo 10-09
Butlers Cabin 10-09
Comply Or Die 11-04
Himalayan Trail 9-09
War Of Attrition 11-10
Tiebreaker: Number of horses entered at Tuesday 10th February: now 117
If I did happen to win please pass on GN review prize to somebody else.
#44
February 10th, 2009 11:12
THIS COMPETITION IS NOW CLOSED………..
Check back later for updates on the disclosure of the weights and we will be announcing the winner of the competition in due course.
Thanks for taking part.
#45
February 10th, 2009 12:17
How wrong could we all be!!
I got the 120 bit right at least!
#46
February 10th, 2009 12:40
I was 1lb out of getting 5 points on two of them
I’m gutted! I would have won :’( (I think)
#47
February 10th, 2009 16:06
As we are very busy updating the rest of the site after the publication of the weights it might be tomorrow before we can give details of winners etc.
Please keep checking back.
#48
February 25th, 2009 13:09
17 withdrawals including Denman, Air Force One, Cane Brake and the late Endless Power.
just waiting on the full list.