The Scottish National 2008 will be the first in our series of races where we will open up a thread for all to discuss the the individual merits of the race itself and any potential bearing it may have on the 2009 Grand National
Previous Winners
A good place to start is to look at the basic details of the last ten previous winners:
Scottish National Winners/Age/Weight/SP/Official Rating
2007 Hot Weld 8-9-9 14/1 124
2006 Run For Paddy 10-10-2 33/1 135
2005 Joe’s Edge 8-10-0 (5oh) 20/1 132
2004 Grey Abbey 10-11-12 12/1 148
2003 Ryalux 10-10-5 15/2 140
2002 Take Control 8-10-6 20/1 140
2001 Gingembre 7-11-2 12/1 137
2000 Paris Pike 8-11-0 5/1JF 143
1999 Young Kenny 8-11-10 5/2F 140
1998 Baronet 8-10-0 (3oh) 7/1 133
Analysis
The victory of Hot Weld was something of a trend breaker last year in that he did not have a top five finish last time out and had a low official rating. If we look upon Hot Weld as a one off it leaves these basic requirements:
Aged 7-10 (10/10)
Official Rating 132-148 (9/10)
Finished in top 5 on last outing (9/10)
In addition no horse that has run in that seasons Grand National has gone on to win the Scottish National so it would appear we can discount any horse who lines up after a trip round the Grand National fences. We can also discount those horses with a poor jumping record as only 2001 winner Gingembre had a record that included more than two falls or unseats.
Stamina will also be a huge consideration and nine out of the last ten winners had demonstrated winning form over at least 3 miles.
So add in:
No more than two falls or unseats (9/10)
Stamina proven at three miles (9/10)
And it looks also safe to remove any horse following on from Aintree.By my reckoning this leaves a shortlist of:
Himalayan Trail
Old Benny
Royal County Star
Boychuk
Newbay Prop
The two that appeal to me most out of those are Midlands Grand National winner Himalayan Trail who would be aiming to complete the same double as Young Kenny and Philip Hobbs’ Boychuk. The former’s claims are more obvious but Boychuk’s recent run at Aintree could be misleading as I thought he was staying on again at the finish whereas the RP comment is ‘weakened after three out’.
Hobbs has obviously targeted this race in recent years with Parsons Legacy 3rd in 2007, Double Honour 4th in 2005 and Gunther McBride favourite for the race and booked for a place at least when falling in 2003. I wouldn’t be surprised if Boychuk puts in an improved performance in the Scottish National.
Are there any trends that you would add or take away from this list?
We will be looking at how the Scottish National has effected the Grand National over the years and how the 2008 may have a bearing on the Aintree race for 2009 in the days to come. Keep an eye out for those posts and keep us updated on your ideas on the Scottish National.
Posted in Grand National 2009 | 58 Comments »